We use cookies to give you the best experience possible. By continuing we’ll assume you’re on board with our cookie policy

Captivity narratives american literature Essay Sample

essay
The whole doc is available only for registered users OPEN DOC

Get Full Essay

Get access to this section to get all help you need with your essay and educational issues.

Get Access

Captivity narratives american literature Essay Sample

Question: Both captivity narratives were written by women. In your opinion, does that give a unique perspective towards the natives? Do not forget to explain your answer. Finally, which narrative did you prefer and why? Captivity Narratives What shapes our viewpoints of other people? I believe that there are many different ways for us to have a viewpoint of something or someone. In the two captivity narratives of Mary Rowlandson and Mary Jemison, some people argue that because both authors are women, they give a unique perspective toward to the Native Indian people. I don’t agree so.

In my opinion, I think our points of view in life are more complex than just because of our sex type. As in the two narratives of Rowlandson and Jemison, although both the writers are women, they gave some different perspectives toward the Indian because they met different people, they were at different ages, and they had different experiences. First of all, the types of people we meet can play an important role to our attitude about them. If we are lucky and meet positive people in our lives, our attitude of life can be more positive. Mary Jemison is an example for that.

She was very lucky when she was captured by Seneca Native people in a raid in Pennsylvania, was adopted by a nice Indian family and was treated as a member of them. They grew her up with their love and made her think she is a “white Indian”. As she mentioned in her narrative essay “Notwithstanding all that has been said against the Indians, in consequence of their cruelties to their enemies—cruelties that I have witnessed, and had abundant proof of—it is a fact that they are naturally kind, tender and peaceable towards their friends, and strictly honest…”.

Her Indian family nurtured a positive perspective about the Native in her mind. On the other hand, Mary Rowlandson was not lucky like that. Her knowing of wrong people made her have a negative viewpoint about the Indian. The Indian people Rowlandson met were not kind to her. They did not feed her well, they killed her children, and they treated her like a prisoner. Both the writers are women, but they have different viewpoints toward the Native is because the people they met were different. One more reason made the two authors have unique points of view about the Native is their ages.

At the different ages, we will have a different view about life. I think this is true in Rowlandson and Jemison situations. When Rowlandson was captured, she was older and had her own family and values. It was hard for her to accept a new change in life and to adapt also. She always kept in her mind about her old life when she had had a family, Christian friends, and freedom. All the set values inside her made her more upset about her current situation. Contrary to Rowlandson, Jemison was a young girl when she was captured. Since she did not have strong values yet, it was easier for her to adapt in a new live.

She started her life over with an Indian family and became an Indian wife. Jemison learned everything from beginning so she considered everything either as good or bad and saw the Indians and white people have both good and bad qualities. They have opposite perspectives about the Indian partly because they viewed life from different ages. The two narratives have two sides of view not because they are women, but because the experiences they had are not similar. Even when both of them are women, they still have different experiences which, I believe, have made strong affection on their perspectives toward the Native.

To Rowlandson, all she had were sad memories and hurts. She wrote “I went with a very heavy heart, and down I sat with the picture of death in my lap”. There were many times she wanted to end her miserable life when she had to see her child’s death, and were treated poorly. I think nobody can stay still in front of their children’s death, but Rowlandson turned to Bible so she can move on. Indian people in her mind are the people who murdered her family, destroyed her hometown, made her a captive and caused the most miserable time of her life.

All that experiences made she put in her mind that Indian are all bad, only white people are good. Jemison’s story is in contrast because she did not remember too much about her time before being captured and she lived very well in an Indian family; therefore, in her mind, they are good people. As a child, Jemison grew up with both the good and evil views about the Native. She stayed in the tribe because that was where she chose to live. With Jemison, Indian became her native people, and she wanted to spend her life with them. Some people can say that women and men have different input perspectives to people, which may be true.

However, every perspective is based on individual experiences. Everyone will have his or her own perspective based on different life experiences. The two authors Rowlandson and Jemison are examples. They are both women but have different viewpoints toward the Native. Between the two narratives, I preferred Jemison’s one because I think that her point of view is more balanced. She did not conclude who is bad or good. She wrote on her logic to convince her readers that every nation has bad and good people. Through Jemison’s narrative, I accept even more that everything has strengths and limitations.

In conclusion, the two narratives were written about the lives of two women when they were captured by the Indian people who reflect their unique perspectives toward the native people. I do not agree that the perspectives are unique because they are both women; but in my opinion, they are unique as the result of the people they met, the ages they were, and the experiences they had. Although people can say that everything in life can be changed if we change our perspectives, I believe some people have more tragedies in life than others. Therefore, I feel thankful for so many peaceful things I have in my life.

We can write a custom essay

According to Your Specific Requirements

Order an essay

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

Value for Life and Nietzsche

What is so significant about the concept of a "value for life? " Are our concepts and commitments only valid in regards to their usefulness? In "The Uses and Disadvantages of History for Life" Nietzsche makes the comment that persons should " serve history only to the extent that history serves life", or perhaps in others words humanity should perceive, comprehend and interpret history only...

Fire Element Symbolism & Meaning

Fire is very powerful in a destructive and constructive way. It destroys hope, civilization, the island, and the relationship between Ralph and Jack. The fire also builds hope, necessities of life, rescue, and power. Fire has both a good and bad side to it throughout the novel. Fire is a symbol which represents the good and bad in each and everyone, and everything in society....

Life style and poor decision making

Adolescents’ aged 15– 19 years old is among extremely populated faction universally with somewhat highest dependence ratio as they are either in schools, colleges or in streets (UNICEF, 2014). Adolescents need to have access to information that will promote their welfare; comprehensive sexual reproductive health information will protect adolescents from unplanned pregnancies and their associated consequence (Nwalo and Anass, 2012) as they are prone to...

What Are Your Values?

Each and every one of us has personal values. Every individual’s personal values are different from one another. One value can be important to one person and not important to other. Personal values are one of the most important characteristics of an individual. These values define who we actually are, what we believe in and where we come from. Personal values are the reflection of...

Life expectancy when cancer has spread

You’ve just learned one of the most important person in your life has cancer. Do you feel shocked, numb, angry,or afraid? Do you feel like life is unfair? One thing is certain—you don’t feel good. My father cancer diagnosis shook the whole family. He was strong,healthy and brave person in my family. But cancer has made him so weak that he couldn’t get out of...

Get Access To The Full Essay
icon
300+
Materials Daily
icon
100,000+ Subjects
2000+ Topics
icon
Free Plagiarism
Checker
icon
All Materials
are Cataloged Well

Sorry, but copying text is forbidden on this website. If you need this or any other sample, we can send it to you via email.

By clicking "SEND", you agree to our terms of service and privacy policy. We'll occasionally send you account related and promo emails.
Sorry, but only registered users have full access

How about getting this access
immediately?

Become a member

Your Answer Is Very Helpful For Us
Thank You A Lot!

logo

Emma Taylor

online

Hi there!
Would you like to get such a paper?
How about getting a customized one?

Couldn't Find What You Looking For?

Get access to our huge knowledge base which is continuously updated

Next Update Will Be About:
14 : 59 : 59
Become a Member